Skip to main content

The Secret Garden by Frances Hodgson Burnett



Brief synopsis (no spoilers): Neglected and eventually orphaned Mary Lennox is sent to live with her Uncle in Misselthwaite Manor. Having been given all that she wants to this point she is spoiled and is constantly yelling and grumpy. However, as she begins to spend time outside and as she learns some of the secrets that Misselthwaite Manor holds she begins to slowly find herself changing. 

Category: Classics

Why I chose this book: It's a classic

My personal opinion: I'm not sorry I read (well, listened) to this story; however, I don't think I'll be recommending it to anyone. The most beautiful and moving parts of the story were the descriptions of the garden coming alive and of Dicken's interactions with the animals.  But the parts about Mary's and Colin's upbringings and and their spoiled brat attitudes became rather annoying (although, I realize they have to start out with bad character traits in order to change throughout the book). The snobby British attitude and degeneration of the natives of India was rather less than tactful as well. 

In the last quarter of the book, the children develop some sort of "spiritualism" about the garden and they begin completing an exercise of chanting and swaying trying to have the "spirit" of the garden in them to strengthen them and give them courage. From my perspective it was a bit unnerving, but most of the characters didn't grow up with religion being a part of their regular lives. And it wasn't too overdone or scary, just something to note.  

Warnings
Language: None
Violence: None 
"Adult" situations: None
Death: Several, off-screen

Movie rating equivalent: PG 

Protagonist description:   

Mary starts out as a proud, demanding, spoiled girl, but goes through a transformation during the story

Dicken is a "creature whisperer" meaning he is good with animals and plants. He seems to know what they say and how they feel and how to take care of them. 

Colin is a sickly invalid boy who constantly throws tantrums when he doesn't get his way. All of the servants, and his own father, are afraid of him. And it's only after another spoiled little girl is willing to stand up to him that he begins to have a change of heart. 

Point of view of story:  3rd Person

Book length: Medium - long

Story flow: Somewhat slow at times

Grammar and spelling issues: None

Character connection (no spoilers): I liked everything I'd heard about Martha (Mary's maid) and Dicken's mother. I'd love to have her as a close friend for her parenting advice and cheerful disposition. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Matched By Ally Condie

Brief synopsis (no spoilers): Cassia has always trusted the Society to make the right choices for her: what to read, what to watch, what to believe. So when Xander's face appears on-screen at her Matching ceremony, Cassia knows he is her ideal mate . . . until she sees Ky Markham's face flash for an instant before the screen fades to black. The Society tells her it's a glitch, a rare malfunction, and that she should focus on the happy life she's destined to lead with Xander. But Cassia can't stop thinking about Ky, and as they slowly fall in love, Cassia begins to doubt the Society's infallibility and is faced with an impossible choice: between Xander and Ky, between the only life she's known and a path that no one else has dared to follow. (Amazon) Category: YA dystopian Why I chose this book: Recommended based on other things I have read, it's been on my list for a while My personal opinion (the review): Of the many popular dystopian/futur

Slave, Warrior, Queen by Morgan Rice

Brief synopsis (no spoilers): Ceres is a young woman (17) living in an oppressive Empire, with an equally oppressive mother. She has ties to a rebellion, and stronger ties to her brothers. She is basically thrown around her world constantly- enslaved, imprisoned, set loose, etc. Each time, she puts herself in the best position to cause the most damage to whatever she hates most. Category : YA fiction, fantasy Why I chose this book : Recommended on the library website My personal opinion : It's complicated. I loved the action, the pace, the unknown special power, the strong female lead character, the general story line. But I disliked the coincidence (see Emma Coats, rule #19, link below)- Ceres got out of trouble so many times. Mostly by fighting, but a couple times by coincidence. I disliked that the "Queen" phase never came, before the end of the book. Maybe that's part of the series, but the next book doesn't mention that in its title. I disliked tha

City of Ashes by Cassandra Clare

Brief synopsis Clary and Jace continue their Shadowhunter path, chasing after demons and one "bad guy" in particular. They're attracted to each other deeply, and they're also siblings. Eww. With the help of werewolves and vampires, the good guys fight a bunch of demons led by a madman. Category YA Fiction Why I chose this book My daughter wanted to read the series, so I decided to give the next book a try. My personal opinion  (the review) I'm very disappointed. The characters are caricatures- complete personifications of one particular trait, each. The plot is predictable (the good guys will win, in the end). Jace and Clary are basically invincible. The only thing the story has going for it is the cliffhangers. Throughout the book, it felt like the story was constantly begging, "wait, don't put me down- there's another surprise coming!" I don't recommend this book at all. Warnings Language: A couple f-words at the beginning, less