Skip to main content

Gathering Blue by Lowis Lowery (2nd Reviewer)

By
Brief synopsis (no spoilers)
Having suffered numerous unnamed disasters (aka, the Ruin), civilization has regressed to a primitive, technology-free state... Kira, a crippled young weaver, has been raised and taught her craft by her mother, after her father was allegedly killed by "beasts." When her mother dies, Kira fears that she will be cast out of the village. Instead, the society's Council of Guardians installs her as caretaker of the Singer's robe, a precious ceremonial garment depicting the history of the world and used at the annual Gathering. From the Publisher's Weekly Review

 Category - Young adult - Dystopia
Why I chose this book - Second in the series

My personal opinion (the review)
Honestly I felt like this book was nothing special and were I not been interested in the series as a whole I probably would not having finished it. The disappearance of Kira's, Thomas's, and Jo's parents does create a questions in the background, but this book didn't create enough tension to make it interesting.

The elements of the song, robe, and staff that tell the history of the people is semi interesting to me. The common thread (no pun intended) between both The Giver and Gathering Blue is how each of these societies has chosen to remember their past. In The Giver it is through the Receiver and Giver and in Gathering Blue it is through the robe, staff, and song. In both cases, history and feeling are kept from the general public. What is Lowery trying to say about the importance of remembering our past? How will this theme be kept through the next two novels?

Warnings (language, violence, "adult" situations, death, etc.) 
Disappearance and death is common, but none are violent or graphic. 

 Movie rating equivalent - PG

 Protagonist description
In a world that sees her useless except for her talent in weaving, Kira exemplifies the need for teamwork, compassion, and thinking beyond the what you see at face value (in individuals and society at large). 

 Point of view of story - First Person

 Book length - Less than a week

 Story flow - It never really dragged, but I wasn't really engaged.

 Grammar and spelling issues - None

 Character connection (no spoilers) -None

For series:
Independent or integral (stand-alone or back story dependent)
Independent

Series review as a whole 
Through these novels Lowrey creates dystopian societies, each with their own unique, disturbing, intricacies. I am waiting to see how Lowery will bring them together. 

 If you only have time for one, read: (which one) 
The Giver
-------------------------------------------------------------------

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Game by Terry Schott

By
Brief synopsis (no spoilers) What if this life is just a simulation? What if our bodies are in another world, plugged into a virtual reality game, and our entire life is just one play in that game? What would our real life be like, if we could experience several full simulated lifespans, in our teen years, and then enter adulthood? That is the premise of this story. Category Sci-Fi Why I chose this book It was either free or discounted on Amazon, and sounded interesting My personal opinion (the review) Too many inconsistencies. For example: The real world is able to view the players in the game in "real time", but time in the game is sped up, so that a week in real life is worth a decade in the virtual world. How do real world people have enough time to experience the virtual world, in real time, while still being accelerated? Danielle enters the game 3 days behind Trew, but she only ends up being 1 year younger. If a week is a decade in the game, then 3 days should have be...
Post a Comment
Read more

Mark of Fire by Richard Phillips

By
Brief synopsis (no spoilers): Two main stories: Carol, the daughter of Lord Rafel, wants to be a magic wielder. As she learns magic and grows in strength, she is unaware that she is being hunted by the greatest wielder in the world. The second story is about a ward of Rafel's, named Blade, who becomes an infamous assassin and works for the king. The king sends Blade to kill Rafel and Carol, but he warns them to flee instead. Blade wanders, to escape the king's justice, but finds himself in his own adventure. Category : Fiction, fantasy, possibly YA Why I chose this book : Kindle First My personal opinion : I really enjoyed the story line, the world the author created, and the depth of the characters. It was easy to lose myself in the story. I also really appreciate that the story is "clean" - no bad language, no sexual situations, etc. I feel comfortable recommending this to my teenage children. Warnings Language: none Violence: fairly frequent fighting "Adult...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Lost Colony by Eoin Colfer

By
This is the fifth book in the Artemis Fowl series Brief synopsis (no spoilers) Artemis continues his adventures, leaning farther and farther away from the villain role, and closer to the hero role. He's quite the teenager, with all the hormones of that age. He has discovered another group of the People (demons), and they need saving. Artemis Fowl to the rescue! Category YA Fiction Why I chose this book Next in the series My personal opinion (the review) Artemis is typically flawless. His plans execute perfectly, and when they don't, coincidence saves him. This time, he fails a bit. He loses some time, his body is a little less perfect, and not all of his plans go through perfectly. I like that- it makes him more real, as a character. Warnings : Language - none Violence - mild "Adult" situations - none Death - yes, but temporary Movie rating equivalent PG Protagonist description Artemis is a genius beyond description. He tends to be prideful a...
Post a Comment
Read more