Skip to main content

The House on Mango Street by Sandra Cisneros

By
Brief Synopsis
Described by others as "Vignettes of a young Latino girl" and her life in Chicago in some previous decade (20th century). She tells about what she sees, experiences, and thinks about through her young perspective.

 Category
Fiction, contemporary classic

 Why I chose this book:
It's on my 8th grade son's book list for school this year

 My personal opinion (the review)
It was easy enough to understand what she was saying (or sometimes referring to in her young language), but sometimes I got lost in all the characters. It didn't have a plot exactly, more just stories or pieces of stories. 
I'm glad I read it (as my child will be reading it later this year in class), but I wouldn't recommend it as a "fun" read.
I originally had thought it was on my 6th grader's reading list and I was a little concerned as I read through it. Some of the things it refers to made me a little unsure about its appropriateness for her tender age/mind, and I considered talking about the book choice with the teacher (because I feel it will bring up discussion on things I'd rather discuss at home). However, it's not inappropriate in the way it is written, and depending on the conversation, the book can be enlightening into the circumstances probably common in that time/place. Then, I checked the syllabus again, and realized it on my 8th grader's reading list for English I for the year. For my 8th grader who is a little more aware of some of the uglier things in life (just by being 2 years older and 3rd year in middle school), I'm ok with him reading and discussing in class. It's not that bad; just too much for a young middle-schooler.

Warnings
Language: possibly one
Violence: yes, but told in past tense (abuse/domestic violence)
"Adult" situations:  yes, but told through the eyes of a youth (so the situation is not explicit) - 
("Adult" situations and other bad stuff referenced, examples: inappropriate contact, shady characters, fortune telling, prejudice, etc.)
Death: yes, but not a known character before death

Movie rating equivalent
PG-13 (it's not as bad as PG-13 movies are usually because it's being told about after it's happened and through a child's eyes, but if it were dramatized, it would be a little edgy.)

Protagonist description
Innocent, hopeful (of a better life), trapped

Point of view of story
First person, Esperanza

Book length
Short

Story flow
Choppy (It's meant to be this way, but I didn't care for it.) 
(Even though the story was penetrating, the disconnected way it's written made it hard for me to follow; too many characters mentioned in passing when some come up again later and some don't. I couldn't tell if the story was continuous chronologically or if it jumped around - also, was it only stories from one year as one of the paragraphs made it sound like, or from multiple years? I felt a little confused sometimes even though I understood what was going on in the moment because I struggled with the intentional lack of flow.)

Grammar and spelling issues
None intentional

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Happily Ever After Kiera Cass

By
Brief synopsis (no spoilers): Short novellas and after stories from the perspective of other main characters from The Selection Series. Includes: -The Prince (with the two bonus chapters), Maxon’s novella -The Guard, Aspen’s novella -The Queen, Amberly’s novella -The Favorite, Marlee’s novella -Three scenes from Celeste’s POV -Lucy’s scene (bonus scene from The One) -The bonus epilogue -Where are they now? Category: YA Why I chose this book: Selection of novellas filling in gaps in The Selection series.  My personal opinion (the review): Of the entire series this was by far and away my favorite. I loved getting to hear parts of the stories from other perspectives. There was also additional details not found in the original story. All my questions or things I wondered about where answered through these stories.  Warnings Language: None  Violence: None "Adult" situations: As with the other novels, a few scenes with more description than I would have liked. ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Tap the Magic Tree by Christie Matheson

By
Summary: Every book needs you to turn the pages. But not every book needs you to tap it, shake it, jiggle it, or even blow it a kiss. Innovative and timeless, Tap the Magic Tree asks you to help one lonely tree change with the seasons. It begins with a bare brown tree. But tap that tree, turn the page, and one bright green leaf has sprouted! Tap again—one, two, three, four—and four more leaves have grown on the next page. Pat, clap, wiggle, jiggle, and see blossoms bloom, apples grow, and the leaves swirl away with the autumn breeze. (Amazon) Attention Span/reading level: Perfect for my three year old. I would say that ages 2-10 would really enjoy something like this. It really keeps kids engaged and makes them feel like part of the story. There is one word to one sentence per page. Good uses for book in teaching: Interaction, that the reader takes part in making the story, what a tree can do (leaves, blossoms, fruit) Favorite part:      Child: The fact that ...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Game by Terry Schott

By
Brief synopsis (no spoilers) What if this life is just a simulation? What if our bodies are in another world, plugged into a virtual reality game, and our entire life is just one play in that game? What would our real life be like, if we could experience several full simulated lifespans, in our teen years, and then enter adulthood? That is the premise of this story. Category Sci-Fi Why I chose this book It was either free or discounted on Amazon, and sounded interesting My personal opinion (the review) Too many inconsistencies. For example: The real world is able to view the players in the game in "real time", but time in the game is sped up, so that a week in real life is worth a decade in the virtual world. How do real world people have enough time to experience the virtual world, in real time, while still being accelerated? Danielle enters the game 3 days behind Trew, but she only ends up being 1 year younger. If a week is a decade in the game, then 3 days should have be...
Post a Comment
Read more